They were among the eight congressional hopefuls removed from the Aug. 6 primary ballot after canvassers agreed with findings from state Bureau of Elections staff, who uncovered nominating petition issues ranging from improper typefaces to more significant issues like evident signature fraud.
Board Chair Mary Ellen Gurewitz, a Democrat, told reporters following the meeting she believed canvassers may need to start personally and closely examining “any instance of fraud, or suspected fraud, that isn’t covered by people who are examining the petitions.”
Related:
The disqualifications mark the second major election cycle in a row in which Michigan canvassers denied ballot access to multiple candidates in high-profile races. In 2022, evidence of a “massive forgery scheme” led canvassers to boot five Republican gubernatorial candidates.
Other candidates disqualified Friday:
- JD Wilson, a Republican running in Michigan’s 1st Congressional District, who had formatting issues with his nominating petitions
- Rhonda Powell, a Democrat running in Michigan’s 10th Congressional District, who did not submit enough signatures ahead of the filing deadline
- Steven Elliott, a Republican running in Michigan’s 12th Congressional District, who the bureau said submitted “71 petitions sheets showing clear indications of fraud”
- Ryan Foster, a Democrat running in Michigan’s 12th Congressional District, who was found to be just shy of the signature threshold
- Hassan H. Nehme, a Republican running in Michigan’s 12th Congressional District, who had several improperly dated petitions
- Anil Kumar, a Democrat running in Michigan’s 10th Congressional District, who the bureau said submitted “at least 47 petition sheets showing clear indications of fraud and … dubious authenticity.”
“This system is messed up,” Foster told the board, arguing it is unfair that his incumbent opponent — U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib, D-Detroit — could afford to pay petition circulators while less affluent candidates could not.
Staff at the Michigan Bureau of Elections recommended disqualifying Beydoun because his nominating petitions listed a post office box rather than a street address required under state law.
Candidates for the U.S. House need 1,000 valid voter signatures to make the ballot, while candidates for the U.S. Senate need 15,000. But the bureau said none of Beydoun’s signatures were valid because of the petition error.
In Friday comments to canvassers, Beydoun argued that he wasn’t trying to be intentionally deceptive with his address, but said that “with today’s political environment … you want everybody in the state to know where you live?”
“I did nothing wrong in my petitions and my filings. I did everything I thought was right underneath the law,” he said, adding that listing a P.O. Box rather than a home address “doesn’t affect the outcome of the signatures.”
But Beydoun did list his home address in filings with the Federal Election Commission, countered Richard Housekamp, one of two Republican canvassers on the four-member board, which agreed that Beydoun did not have enough valid signatures to make the ballot.
“We are bound not only by the words of the statute, but by judicial interpretation,” said Gurewitz, who said she was sympathetic to Beydoun’s arguments, but “it is what it is.”
Snyder, the 8th district congressional candidate, had initially filed to run for U.S. Senate but in March changed her focus to the U.S. House. The Bureau of Elections determined 980 of the 1,079 signatures she filed were valid, dropping her below the threshold required to make the ballot.
Among those surviving signature challenges were Curtis Hertel, the lone Democrat running against Republican Tom Barrett in Michigan’s 7th Congressional District, and U.S. Rep. Elissa Slotkin, the Democratic frontrunner for the U.S. Senate race Beydoun was disqualified from.
